Photo: Michael M. Santiago / Getty Images News / Getty Images
Former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo has made education a central focus of his independent campaign for New York City mayor, advocating for the expansion of gifted and talented programs and the establishment of more specialized high schools. Cuomo's stance presents a stark contrast to Democratic frontrunner Zohran Mamdani, who has proposed eliminating gifted programs for kindergarteners.
Cuomo argues that expanding these programs will provide more opportunities for academically advanced students, particularly those from historically marginalized backgrounds. He believes that eliminating such programs would hinder the chances of students receiving a first-class education in public schools. According to ABC7NY, Cuomo stated, "The Democratic ideal has always been about providing more opportunities for historically marginalized students to access these programs—not eliminating academic excellence altogether."
Mamdani's proposal to end gifted programs for young children has sparked debate, with critics arguing that it could hold back gifted students in the name of equity. Mamdani's plan would retain gifted classes starting in the third grade and maintain selective high schools, which he believes offer more advanced programming than typical American school districts. Vox reports that Mamdani's proposal comes amid a broader debate within the Democratic Party about education policy, with some progressives pushing to restrict gifted programs due to concerns about racial inequities.
The issue of gifted programs has been contentious in New York City, where racial disparities are evident. As Chalkbeat notes, 75% of students in gifted programs are white or Asian, despite the city's public school population being predominantly Black and Latino. Recent changes to the admissions process, such as shifting from a test-based system to one based on teacher recommendations, have increased diversity in these programs.
Cuomo's proposal to expand gifted programs aligns with his belief in providing more educational opportunities, while Mamdani's plan reflects a focus on equity and diversity. The outcome of this debate could significantly impact the future of New York City's education system.
Photo Credit: Getty Images